Sage Payroll logo

Sage Payroll

Verified Listing

HMRC recognised cloud payroll with built in HR tools and Sage Copilot, from £12 a month

Verified reviews for Sage Payroll

We may earn a commission if you buy via links on this page. It never affects how we rate software — how we make money.

4.4

22 reviews

  • 5
    13
  • 4
    6
  • 3
    2
  • 2
    1
  • 1
    0
Positive 86%Neutral 9%Negative 5%
Write a Review
S

Stephen Garrity

Owner, Garrity Landscapes

Landscaping2-10 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 1-2 years
5.0
Reviewed on 14 March 2026

Five staff, £12 a month, no complaints

For a small crew like ours the Essentials plan covers everything. Started on the 90% offer so it cost pennies while I learned it, and even at full price it is less than an hour of my time is worth.

Ease of use
5.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
5.0
Functionality
4.0
Pros

Pay run takes me ten minutes on the last Friday of the month, done from the van more than once. The lads get payslips on their phones. HMRC side is completely handled.

Cons

Seasonal workers coming and going means adding and removing employees, and beyond the included five it charges per head. Fair enough, but budget for it if your headcount swings.

Was this helpful? · 12
K

Krishnan IyerVerified reviewer

Practice Owner, KI Accounting Services

LinkedIn verified
Accounting2-10 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 2+ years
5.0
Reviewed on 23 February 2026

I run nine client payrolls on it

As a small practice we tested most of the cloud payroll options. Sage won on the balance of price, HMRC reliability and how little training clients need when they want to see their own numbers.

Ease of use
4.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
5.0
Functionality
5.0
Pros

Never once had an RTI submission fail or go missing in three years, which I cannot say for every product I have used. Auto enrolment assessments are right every time. The price per company is sensible for bureau style use.

Cons

Switching between client companies takes more clicks than it should. A proper bureau dashboard across all clients would save me real time.

Was this helpful? · 25
C

Cheryl AnandVerified reviewer

Bookkeeper, CA Bookkeeping

LinkedIn verified
AccountingSelf-employed employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 2+ years
5.0
Reviewed on 9 February 2026

My recommendation for every small client who asks

Clients ask me what payroll to use roughly once a month. Unless they have something unusual going on, this is my answer, mostly because I know they will not break it and I will not be untangling anything in January.

Ease of use
5.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
5.0
Functionality
4.0
Pros

Hard to make an uncorrectable mistake, and corrections when needed are clean with a proper trail. New starter and leaver processing is well guided. Consistent between clients so my process notes work everywhere.

Cons

Price rises have arrived most years, modest each time but the direction is the same. Grandfathered pricing for long standing customers would be a nice gesture.

Was this helpful? · 17
M

Malcolm Treharne

Director, Treharne Bros Butchers

Retail2-10 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 2+ years
4.0
Reviewed on 17 January 2026

Second generation shop, first generation on proper payroll

Dad did the wages in a ledger book for forty years. The accountant insisted we modernise and picked Sage. Two years on I will admit she was right.

Ease of use
4.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
4.0
Functionality
4.0
Pros

Weekly pay runs are quick once your staff are set up. Holiday pay for the Saturday staff calculated properly. The accountant logs in herself at year end which saves us both time.

Cons

Weekly payroll means you are in it every week obviously, and the odd slow afternoon on the site is more noticeable. Nothing that has made me want to go back to the ledger.

Was this helpful? · 10
G

Gerald Mostyn

Company Secretary, Mostyn Holdings

Investment Management2-10 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 6-12 months
3.0
Reviewed on 5 January 2026

Does directors payroll fine, wants to be more than we need

We run directors salaries and little else. It handles that perfectly well but the product increasingly pushes HR features, Copilot suggestions and upgrade prompts at a company that just wants four payslips a month.

Ease of use
3.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
3.0
Functionality
3.0
Pros

Directors NI calculated on the annual basis correctly, which simpler tools get wrong. Reliable RTI. Support competent on the one occasion needed.

Cons

Interface busy with features we will never use. Would happily pay less for a directors only mode with half the screens.

Was this helpful? · 7
D

Duncan Faircloth

General Manager, The Ploughman’s Rest

Hospitality11-50 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 1-2 years
4.0
Reviewed on 30 December 2025

Pub payroll with students and seasonal staff

High staff turnover is the reality of a pub and the starter and leaver workflows cope well. P45s generated properly, student loan deductions picked up from the starter checklist, holiday accrual for casual staff tracked.

Ease of use
4.0
Customer service
5.0
Value for money
4.0
Functionality
4.0
Pros

Starters and leavers are quick. Support sorted a duplicated employee record inside one phone call. The pay run reminds you about outstanding tax code notices before you run.

Cons

Tronc and tips distribution is manual, a hospitality feature set would be welcome. Rota features need Premium which we have not stretched to.

Was this helpful? · 11
A

Alan WhitcombeVerified reviewer

Managing Director, Whitcombe Precision Engineering

LinkedIn verified
Mechanical Engineering11-50 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 2+ years
4.0
Reviewed on 15 December 2025

Solid payroll, HR side feels bolted on

The payroll half is excellent and has never let us down across three tax year changes. The HR features are useful but you can tell they came from a different product, the navigation between the two halves is not seamless.

Ease of use
4.0
Customer service
3.0
Value for money
4.0
Functionality
4.0
Pros

April tax changes just appear, no update to install, no panic. Pension files upload to Nest without editing. P60s at year end took minutes for eighteen staff.

Cons

Jumping between payroll and the HR area feels like switching apps. Had one support query about statutory paternity that took three contacts to get a straight answer.

Was this helpful? · 16
N

Nadia KaminskaVerified reviewer

HR Manager, Ferrocrest Manufacturing

LinkedIn verified
Manufacturing51-200 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 1-2 years
3.0
Reviewed on 19 November 2025

Fine to about fifty staff, strained beyond that

We run just over sixty on it and while it copes, you feel the edges. Shift premiums and overtime rules need manual handling every run and the per employee pricing adds up at our size.

Ease of use
3.0
Customer service
3.0
Value for money
4.0
Functionality
3.0
Pros

Core calculations always correct. The self service portal cut the payslip reprint requests to zero. Onboarding checklists keep the paperwork consistent.

Cons

No rule builder for complex overtime and shift premiums, we prepare those in a spreadsheet and import. At sixty plus employees the per head charges make it worth comparing against bigger payroll platforms.

Was this helpful? · 20
R

Raymond Petherick

Owner, Petherick Marine Services

Maritime2-10 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 2+ years
5.0
Reviewed on 2 November 2025

Three tax years in, it has never once been the problem

Running a small business means something is always on fire. In three years payroll has not been the fire, not once, and that reliability is worth more than any feature.

Ease of use
4.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
5.0
Functionality
4.0
Pros

April changes handled invisibly. A tax code change for one of the engineers arrived from HMRC into the software before the paper letter reached him. Payslip portal means no reprints.

Cons

They retired a report layout I liked in an update without much notice. Found an equivalent but release notes could be clearer about what is changing.

Was this helpful? · 13
F

Frank DelaceyVerified reviewer

Managing Partner, Delacey & Rowe Architects

LinkedIn verified
Architecture & Planning11-50 employeesUnited KingdomUsed: 2+ years
5.0
Reviewed on 21 October 2025

Quietly excellent, which is exactly what payroll should be

Good payroll software should be boring and this is beautifully boring. Twenty two staff paid correctly on the 28th of every month for two and a half years, and the one complexity we have, salary sacrifice pensions for the partners, handled without workarounds.

Ease of use
4.0
Customer service
4.0
Value for money
4.0
Functionality
5.0
Pros

Salary sacrifice configured properly with the right NI treatment. Year end is an afternoon, not a week. Employee portal adoption was immediate, even from the partners who resist all technology.

Cons

The dashboards on login are more marketing than information, I click past them every time. Let me set my landing page.

Was this helpful? · 14